Reservation
+1 920-532-9090
Visit Us
505 Washington St, Wrightstown, WI 54180, United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Adult Lunchables
Fox River, Blu Bobber (Blueberry Ale), Wi 5.5
Pacifico Mexican Lager, Sinaloa 4.5
Narragansett Lager, Ri 5
About
Lost Key Tap Restaurant
If you find yourself in Wrightstown, Wisconsin, make sure to visit the gem known as Lost Key Tap Restaurant, located at 505 Washington St. This delightful establishment is quickly becoming a local favorite, renowned for its inviting atmosphere, high-quality dishes, and exceptional service.
Dining at Lost Key Tap feels like an adventure where taste and comfort intertwine. Customer reviews reflect a passionate commitment to culinary excellence. For example, one patron raved about the cheesy rice risotto, calling it “wicked good,” while another highlighted the macadamia nut crusted walleye as a “must-try.” Their attention to detail and commitment to flavor create an experience that's hard to forget.
One standout feature is their diverse menu that caters to varied palates. Diners have enjoyed dishes like bone marrow appetizers and unique enticements like the featured duck dish, consistently described as “absolutely amazing.” The culinary creativity shines through with items like Asiago stuffed gnocchi, which is a dreamy pasta encased in rich sauces that tantalize the taste buds.
Beyond the food, the service at Lost Key Tap deserves special mention. Patrons frequently commend the staff, noting how friendly and attentive they are. The personal touch, including visits from the chef and an attentive team led by knowledgeable servers, makes each visit feel special. For those looking for a cozy date night spot or a celebratory dinner, this restaurant hits the mark every time.
The ambiance is just as noteworthy. With a thoughtfully curated music selection and a warm, inviting decor, the dining experience transcends mere eating; it becomes a joyous memory. As one guest put it, “they went above and beyond in service,” illustrating the restaurant's earnest commitment to making every visitor's experience remarkable.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Lost Key Tap Restaurant proves to be more than just a meal; it’s an invitation to savor culinary artistry paired with stellar service. Make your reservations soon — you certainly don’t want to miss out on this delightful dining experience!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Incredible food! I had the cheesy rice (risotto) and it was wicked good. My partner had the macadamia nut crusted walleye, and we shared and I am so happy we did, Lost Key has a high quality menu. Our waitress and host were fantastic and our chef even came over to see if we had a good meal! The atmosphere is really nice too, they have good taste in music -where we sat had a cool vibe / view and their bar is sweet. They went above and beyond in service, and care taken with both the food and the incredible humans who make it happen. We will definitely be back! ”
“ Went to Lost Key Tap the tonight. We did not have reservations but we're there right at 5 so they fit us in! I will make sure to make reservations going forward as it would be a shame to not be able to get in if my heart is set on eating there! My husband and I both shared the bone marrow appetizer. For mains we both had the featured duck dish as you don't always see duck. It was absolutely amazing!! Our server Josh was attentive and helpful! We finished with creme brulee that you could see the dots of vanilla bean in!!! Absolutely a great experience! It was our second visit but we plan on making it part of our regular rotation. ”
“ We decided to try a new place, what a great decision it was! The food, drinks & over the top service by Kaitlyn was excellent! This is a “must try” We will be back! ”
“ Lost Key Tap is an excellent spot. It’s Outside of the main parts of the valley, so it’s kind of a hidden gem. I enjoy it because so many places in Appleton that are good are always packed, the wait for a table is long, and they don’t take reservations ahead of time. LKT was the opposite. They took reservations, but they had seating available regardless, it wasn’t packed and loud, and the interior was very inviting. I had the NY Strip. Probably my favorite in the valley as of now. The way they made the smashed potatoes crispy and put them on a bed of garlic and herbs was top tier, so so good! The steak was cooked perfectly. My wife had the stuff gnocchi and the made in house pasta was top tier as well. Delicate, lump Asiago stuffed pillows of joy in a rich and flavorful sauce. Superb. If you are celebrating, doing date night, taking someone out for dinner, or even having a treat yourself day, LKT is the right call. They will take care of you WELL. They’re doing upscale casual dining right and are an excellent, much needed addition to the local food scene. ”
“ We went here for our anniversary and it was amazing! Josh was our server and Tyler was our bartender! Both extremely great people, super friendly and amazing. Mike did amazing on all the food. Definitely will be coming back to see everyone! The owner Danny was very personable and made us feel very welcomed!! ”
“ If you need to break away from what some tout as fine dining, go to Lost Key Tap to enjoy a great meal, service and surroundings. I was surprised by the comfortable seating and exceptional service. I had the Seared Tuna and the Scallops. Quality ingredients are the foundation of the meal I enjoyed. This the the environment to enjoy and casual meal, where attention to the experience is the priority ”
“ Just a fantastic place to stop by for a relaxing casual lunch. If you want that upscale but relaxed dinner atmosphere it has all of that too. All the seating is comfortable. Come down and experience this hidden gem. ”
“ We stopped here yesterday for a late lunch/early dinner. First of all, the interior is lovely and immaculate. We sat at the bar and since it was an odd time of day, had the place to ourselves. The incredibly nice owner greeted and served us. We both ordered the Trout dinner and it was brought out promptly. So delicious! This is one of our new favorite places and it’s just a short drive from Appleton, well worth the trip! ”